I wrote a long comment on SG’s recent review of Strangers in Their Own Land. Still pondering, but I want to call for some serious self reflection.
Thanks for the good review. It does sometimes feel like a foreign country to visit parts of the US. Anthropological/sociological studies like this across political (or religious) divides are always eye openers and attract a certain fascination. I do think it’s relevant to consider the “symbolic capitalism” angle of Musa al-Gharbi. (I’m not as fond of Henderson’s “luxury beliefs”.) I appreciate attempts to understand and even to make friends. But studies like this (I haven’t read this particular book) often feel to me like they judge and subtly look down not just on how people live (and struggle) but on an apparent inability of the “foreign” others to understand them — while they feel they can (magnanimously, laudably) reach across any cultural gap. I dare say there is more gap crossing both ways than meets the eye. I dunno. I grew up not in the Deep South but in a decidedly blue collar and less educated rural Michigan during mass unemployment with the collapse of the auto industry. I actually think a lot of Americans are first generation “elites” who manage to get advanced education and are lucky enough to attain financial security to create generational cultural shift for their families. But it doesn’t mean they forget where they came from (the good and the bad). Hillbilly Elegy comes to mind. And yet there are also generationally maintained life ways that don’t change, or even degrade over time. Longitudinal studies might be just as or more interesting than geographical comparisons. Also, maybe you couldn’t have academic “studies” going the other way, but I bet there’s some real wisdom to be had from reversing the perspective. It was for comedic effect, of course, and would be too politically incorrect today, but old TV shows like the Beverly Hillbillies managed to put the shoe on the other foot. Absurdities abound on all sides.
Tracy Gustilo on Taking Readings sgreenleaf.substack.com